Should You Repair or Replace a Leaky Faucet in Amarillo?

Should You Repair or Replace a Leaky Faucet in Amarillo?

You’re lying in bed, it’s past midnight, and all is quiet in your Amarillo home. Then you hear it.
Drip… drip… drip. At first, it sounds like nothing. But after a while? It feels like water torture. You start wondering if that little drip is just annoying, or if it’s actually draining your money, one drop at a time.

So now you’re asking yourself the big question: Should I repair this faucet… or replace it altogether?

Don’t worry. You’re not the only one in Amarillo facing this drip dilemma. At Plumbing Amarillo TX, we get calls about this every single week. Let’s help you decide what’s best, without all the guesswork.

Why That Little Drip Deserves Attention?


It may seem harmless. After all, it’s just a slow leak, right? But here’s the thing:

A faucet that drips once per second can waste over 3,000 gallons of water every year. That’s not just a hit on your water bill, it’s a hit on Amarillo’s water supply too.

Here in the Texas Panhandle, where droughts aren’t exactly rare, wasting water isn’t just bad, it’s expensive and unwise. Every gallon counts. And beyond the waste? Leaky faucets can lead to:

  • Mold growth around the sink area
  • Water stains on your countertop or under the sink
  • Rust or mineral buildup
  • Higher water bills
  • Endless frustration

What’s Actually Leaking?

Not all faucet leaks are the same. Some are easy fixes. Others? Not so much. Take a minute to figure out where the leak is coming from:

  • Dripping from the spout? That usually means a worn-out washer or cartridge.
  • Leaking around the handle or base? Could be a broken seal or corroded part.
  • Leaking underneath the sink? Now we’re in bigger territory, think pipe damage or deeper plumbing issues.

Sometimes, what looks like a faucet issue is actually a water pressure problem or corrosion hiding in your plumbing lines. This is where calling us can really save you time and headaches. We’ve got the tools (and experience) to find the real cause fast.

When You Should Just Repair the Faucet

If your faucet is still fairly new or the leak just started, repairing might be all you need. Here are good signs that a repair will do the trick:

  • Faucet is under 10 years old
  • The leak is coming from the spout or handle only
  • The finish still looks good (no rust or corrosion)
  • The parts needed are easy to find
  • It hasn’t been repaired multiple times already

Common repairs include:

  • Replacing washers
  • Swapping out O-rings
  • Installing a new cartridge
  • Tightening loose parts

These fixes can take as little as 15–30 minutes. If you’re good with tools, you might even do it yourself. (Just don’t forget to shut off the water first, trust us, we’ve seen some surprise water shows.)


More Reading:


When It’s Smarter to Replace the Whole Faucet

Sometimes, fixing the faucet is like putting a Band-Aid on a worn-out tire. You might buy yourself a little time, but not for long. Here’s when replacing your faucet makes more sense:

  • It’s over 10–15 years old
  • The faucet has been repaired more than once
  • The leak keeps coming back
  • You see rust, corrosion, or cracks
  • It doesn’t match your sink or decor anymore
  • You want a more water-efficient model

Let’s be real, old faucets can look worn and out of place. And with new models offering features like touchless sensors, pull-out sprayers, and water-saving designs, it might be the perfect excuse for an upgrade.

Even if the new one costs more up front, it can save you money in the long run with lower water usage and fewer future problems.

What About Amarillo Water?

This part is important. Amarillo has hard water. That means your faucet is getting hit with minerals every single day. Over time, those minerals can:

  • Clog the faucet aerator
  • Eat away at seals and washers
  • Leave behind white crusty buildup
  • Shorten the life of the faucet

So even if you take great care of your faucet, the water itself might still be doing damage.

Call the Local Pros

Whether it’s a quick fix or a full replacement, the team at Plumbing Amarillo TX is here for you.

We know Amarillo homes inside and out. We’ve helped thousands of homeowners in the area fix everything from leaky faucets to full pipe bursts, and everything in between.

We don’t upsell, we don’t talk in circles, and we don’t leave a mess behind. We just fix the problem and leave you with peace of mind.

Final Thoughts

A leaky faucet isn’t just a drip, it’s a warning sign. Whether it needs a small fix or a complete swap, it’s better to handle it now than wait until it turns into a bigger problem.

If your faucet’s doing more dripping than pouring, don’t just live with it. Reach out to Plumbing Amarillo TX and we’ll help you figure out the smartest, fastest, and most cost-friendly solution. Because no one should lose sleep over a leaky faucet.

Attribution: Cover Photo by FreePik


More Reading: